The Power of “I Don’t Know”: How Admitting Uncertainty Builds Trust

In many workplaces, confidence is prized above all else. We’re encouraged to have answers ready, to lead with conviction, and to appear certain even when we’re not. But beneath that polished surface, something important often gets lost—honesty.

The truth is, no one has all the answers. And pretending to can quietly erode credibility faster than an honest admission ever will. Whether you’re a leader or a team member, learning to say “I don’t know” can be one of the most powerful things you do for your team.

Far from signaling weakness, admitting uncertainty builds trust. It shows humility, authenticity, and a willingness to learn—all qualities that strengthen collaboration and deepen respect.

Participants immerse in a Be You Disco mindfulness moment—tuning into music, breath, and shared energy to foster calm, connection, and authentic presence.

The Myth of Always Knowing

Somewhere along the way, many of us were taught that leadership means having everything figured out. We equate authority with certainty, and certainty with competence. The result? A culture where people hesitate to admit gaps in their knowledge or mistakes in their decisions.

But here’s the irony: the more leaders pretend to know everything, the less their teams trust them. People can sense when someone is bluffing or overconfident. It creates distance rather than connection.

In contrast, when a leader says, “I’m not sure, but let’s find out,” they model intellectual honesty and teamwork. They replace ego with curiosity—and that’s when genuine problem-solving begins.

The Hidden Power of Humility

Humility is often misunderstood as self-doubt. In reality, it’s quiet strength—the confidence to acknowledge what you don’t know without fear of losing credibility.

When a leader practices humility, it invites others to do the same. Suddenly, the team feels permission to ask questions, seek feedback, and share imperfect ideas. Walls come down, and collaboration deepens.

Consider this simple truth: people don’t trust perfection—they trust realness. When you show that you’re human, approachable, and still learning, you create an environment where others can be too.

Story 1: The Project Manager Who Said, “I Don’t Know”

During a high-stakes product launch, a project manager named Lila was asked by an executive about a technical issue that had just surfaced. All eyes turned to her in the meeting. Instead of guessing or deflecting, she paused and said, “I don’t know the answer yet—but I’ll find out and get back to you by tomorrow.”

The room was silent for a moment. Then the tension eased. Her honesty set the tone for the entire team to be transparent about what they did and didn’t know. By the end of the week, they had not only solved the issue but improved their communication process.

Lila didn’t lose respect; she gained it. Her willingness to admit uncertainty built trust and created a culture of ownership and openness.

Story 2: The Team That Learned Together

In another company, a software development team faced a sudden system failure. Instead of assigning blame, their team lead gathered everyone and said, “I don’t have all the answers here, but together, we’ll figure it out.”

That moment of humility shifted everything. Team members felt empowered to speak up, share insights, and even question the lead’s assumptions. Within hours, they had identified the issue and implemented a fix.

Later, in a reflection session, one engineer said, “It’s the first time I’ve felt safe saying ‘I don’t know’ without fear of judgment.”

That’s the kind of psychological safety that fuels creativity, trust, and growth.

Joy in motion — participants dance freely under the sun at a Be You Disco event, celebrating connection, music, and authentic self-expression.

Why “I Don’t Know” Builds Trust

Saying “I don’t know” is more than a phrase—it’s an act of integrity. It communicates honesty, respect, and partnership.

Here’s why admitting uncertainty builds trust:

It signals authenticity.

People trust those who are genuine. Admitting uncertainty shows that you value truth over image.

It invites collaboration.

When a leader admits they don’t know, it opens space for others to contribute ideas and expertise.

It normalizes learning.

Curiosity thrives in environments where not knowing is seen as a beginning, not a failure.

It strengthens accountability.

Saying “I don’t know right now” implies responsibility to find out, which reinforces dependability and follow-through.

It models courage.

Vulnerability requires bravery. Each time someone admits uncertainty, they make it safer for others to do the same.

Reflection: What Happens When You Always Have the Answers?

• Take a moment to reflect on your own habits:

• How often do you feel pressure to have an immediate answer?

• When was the last time you said, “I don’t know,” out loud?

• What kind of tone would it set if you made that phrase part of your leadership language?

If you never admit uncertainty, your team may learn to hide their own. They may avoid risk, stop asking questions, and lose confidence in their own curiosity. But if you show that it’s okay not to know everything, you build a culture that values growth over perfection.

How to Practice Saying “I Don’t Know”

If this feels uncomfortable at first, you’re not alone. Here are a few practical ways to make this shift more natural:

Reframe it as strength, not lack.

Instead of fearing loss of credibility, remember that honesty enhances it.

• Pair it with intention.

Add a next step: “I don’t know yet, but I’ll find out by Friday.” This keeps confidence intact while remaining transparent.

• Invite input.

Try, “I’m not sure—what do you think?” This empowers your team and turns uncertainty into a collaborative moment.

• Reflect after the fact.

Notice how people respond when you’re honest. Often, you’ll find they relax, respect you more, and mirror your openness.

Over time, you’ll find that the more you practice honesty, the easier it becomes—and the more trust you build.

The Ripple Effect of Honest Leadership

Connection in motion — participants at a Be You Disco event join hands and share laughter under the lights, embodying the spirit of togetherness and authentic expression.

When honesty becomes the norm, trust deepens across every level of a team. Meetings become more productive, problem-solving becomes faster, and communication becomes real.

People stop performing competence and start embodying collaboration. They realize that leadership isn’t about knowing everything—it’s about creating an environment where everyone can learn something.

In the end, the power of “I don’t know” isn’t just in admitting uncertainty—it’s in what follows. It’s the courage to stay curious, the humility to listen, and the integrity to keep learning together.

Because when admitting uncertainty builds trust, everyone wins: the leader, the team, and the work itself.